SPF, DKIM and DMARC: A Plain-English Guide for Small Businesses
A client gets an email from your office manager. It has your logo, your signature block and your domain in the From line, and it asks them to send next month’s payment to a new bank account. Your office manager never wrote it.
Email doesn’t check who sent a message, so anyone can put your address in the From line. Three settings on your domain, called SPF, DKIM and DMARC, let the receiving side check that claim and refuse the fakes. If you use Microsoft 365, you probably set up the first one when you added your domain. The other two take extra steps, and the third is the one that blocks forgeries.
What each one does
- SPF is a list of the services allowed to send email for your domain, like Microsoft 365 or your newsletter tool.
- DKIM puts a digital signature on your outgoing mail, so the receiver can tell it came from you and wasn’t changed on the way.
- DMARC ties the first two to the From address people see. It tells receiving servers what to do with mail that fails, from “deliver it anyway” to “reject it,” and it sends you reports on who is sending mail as your domain.
Without DMARC, a forger can pass SPF using their own domain behind the scenes while still showing yours in the From line. DMARC closes that gap.
Why it matters more now
Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft’s Outlook.com have all tightened their rules. Anyone sending to Gmail or Yahoo needs at least SPF or DKIM, and businesses that send in large volume need all three. Mail that doesn’t measure up is more likely to land in junk or be turned away.
Even if you never send in bulk, the same three settings are what keep your domain from being used against your own clients.
Setting them up, in the right order
- List everything that sends email as your domain. Microsoft 365 is the obvious one. Also think about your website’s contact form, your accounting or invoicing software, your newsletter tool, your CRM, and any phone system that emails voicemails. Anything you miss here will start failing later.
- Get SPF right. Your domain gets one SPF record listing every service from step one. The most common mistake is adding a second SPF record for a new service. Two records break SPF for the whole domain, so new services get added to the existing one. A record that tries to list too many services can also break, so keep it lean.
- Turn on DKIM for each service. Microsoft 365 doesn’t sign mail with your own domain until you set it up, and your other sending services each have their own DKIM setup.
- Start DMARC in monitoring mode. Your first DMARC setting should only watch. Send the reports to a shared mailbox, not one person’s inbox, and use a reporting service to make them readable. They’ll show you any sender you missed in step one.
- Tighten it. Once your real mail is passing, move from monitoring to sending failures to junk, then to rejecting them. Microsoft recommends working up to rejection gradually. Just don’t stop at monitoring, because at that setting receivers aren’t told to do anything about forgeries.
Two more habits help. Domains you own but don’t use for email, like an old company name, should have records saying no mail ever comes from them, so forgers can’t borrow those either. And for newsletter and marketing tools, Microsoft suggests sending from a subdomain, like news.yourdomain.com, so a problem with that tool doesn’t drag down your everyday email.
What these settings won’t stop
SPF, DKIM and DMARC stop someone from using your exact domain. That’s a real gain, and it’s narrower than people expect.
- Look-alike domains. The DMARC standard says plainly that it doesn’t deal with similar-looking domain names or fake display names. A forger who registers yourfirm-billing.com can set all three up perfectly for that domain.
- Hacked mailboxes. If someone steals a staff member’s password and sends from their real account, that mail really does come from your domain. Multi-factor authentication is the defense there, along with the other settings in the Microsoft 365 security settings small businesses miss.
- Forgeries sent to you. Your settings protect other people from fakes of your domain. Whether forged mail reaches your own staff depends on your own email filtering.
That’s why the payment-change email at the top of this post still deserves a phone call to a number you already have, even with all three in place.
Checking where you stand
Free online lookup tools will show whether your domain has SPF and DMARC records. If DMARC is missing, or it’s set to monitor and nobody reads the reports, there’s work to do.
Setting up SPF, DKIM and DMARC is part of our Microsoft 365 management, which we offer together with managed IT. If you’re not sure what your records say or who else sends as your domain, tell us about your setup.
Sources
- Google: Email sender guidelines and Yahoo: Sender best practices
- Microsoft Outlook.com: Policies for senders
- Microsoft Learn: set up SPF, DKIM and DMARC for Microsoft 365
- The DMARC standard (RFC 9989)
Questions this post answers
What is the difference between SPF, DKIM and DMARC?
SPF is a list of the services allowed to send email for your domain. DKIM puts a digital signature on your outgoing mail, so the receiver can tell it came from you and wasn’t changed on the way. DMARC ties the first two to the From address people see, tells receiving servers what to do with mail that fails, and sends you reports on who is sending mail as your domain.
Can a domain have two SPF records?
No. Your domain gets one SPF record listing every service that sends email for it. Two records break SPF for the whole domain, so new services get added to the existing one.
Does DMARC stop look-alike domains?
No. The DMARC standard says plainly that it doesn’t deal with similar-looking domain names or fake display names. A forger who registers a look-alike domain can set all three up perfectly for that domain. A hacked mailbox also gets through, because that mail really does come from your domain.
What a Cyber Risk Assessment Should Include
A scan is not an assessment. What a real cyber risk assessment covers for a small business, what you should get back,…
How to Choose a Cybersecurity Company in Columbus
Cybersecurity companies sell very different things under the same words. How to work out which kind you need, who actually does the…
Your First Hour After a Ransomware Attack
What to do in the first sixty minutes, in order, including the two calls people delay and the one instinct that destroys…